It's probably some streak of smug superiority but I can't help being attracted by writers who base their ideas on some technical issue that they get totally and provably wrong. Usually if you see a mention of "entropy" or "Heisenberg" you can pretty much be guaranteed it's completely wrong unless coming from an actual science writer. (A personal favorite is when Charles Rutheiser claims in Imagineering Atlanta that fractals are non-Euclidean, showing not even a superficial understanding.)
So critic Mick LaSalle in the San Francisco Chronicle wrote a review of Monster House that blithely dismisses pretty much all animation prior to it, mainly because of some kind of facial abilities in the new technology. Or as he puts it "Moreover, if the actor is thinking or is full of doubt, the technology will be able to render subtle qualities of pensiveness or doubt in the animation." Which actually might be good since most actual live actors can't render these subtle qualities or at least they're in films where such skills are not needed.
Pixar animator Jeffrey Pidgeon wrote a fine rebuttal.
Monday, July 31, 2006
Thursday, July 13, 2006
who'd a thunk: linguist humor
http://mercury.ccil.org/%7Ecowan/essential.html
English is essentially a West Germanic language that's trying very hard to look like a Romance one.
Danish is essentially Swedish run backwards at half speed.
French is essentially Latin spoken by a drunken Roman soldier.
[and it just goes on and on....]
English is essentially a West Germanic language that's trying very hard to look like a Romance one.
Danish is essentially Swedish run backwards at half speed.
French is essentially Latin spoken by a drunken Roman soldier.
[and it just goes on and on....]
Wednesday, July 5, 2006
still here....
When I started the blog however long back (three years? four?) I knew it wouldn't be updated every week. Still, this may be the longest it's gone silent. Consider it conceptual art blogging.
Monday, May 1, 2006
Sunday, April 23, 2006
two art books
Two books with similar titles that I both ran across in libraries (one academic, one public) while looking for something else.
Lyle Rexer’s How to Look at Outsider Art (2005) doesn’t sound particularly promising and lives up to such unpromise. After all, doesn’t outsider art more than any other create its own terms? Not that an introduction or overview wouldn’t be useful but the primary value to Rexer’s book is as a sporadic survey. There are a few interesting artists I didn’t know about and unfamiliar bits about others I did but Rexer is far too mired in run-of-the-mill art critical thinking to help much with this art. In other words, timid and watered-down philosophy takes precedence over actually experiencing the art work. Much of his concern is exterior (outside the outsider art) even leading him to propose a taxonomy based on the mental status of the artist, an activity more appropriate to a therapist than a critic. While such information is undeniably of interest, it’s not the major point. You also wonder about most factual information when he tells us about the Borges story “Tlon, Uqbar, and Orbis Tertius” which manages to have two errors in one title (it’s actually “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” and the umlaut couldn’t have posed a problem considering how often Wölfli is mentioned). Elsewhere he tries to mention a Ken Grimes painting that resembles a circuit diagram as an example of outsiders gravitating to science fiction despite the obvious fact that there’s nothing remotely science fictional about this since it’s based on decades-old electrical symbols.
Though Patrick de Rynck’s How to Read a Painting: Lessons from the Old Masters (2004) seemed more promising, it’s actually of almost no value. The basic idea is to explore important elements of pre-modern painting that elude most of us nowadays. The format is two pages per painting (100 paintings in all) which each work getting a full view then enlargments of specific icons, characters or actions with accompanying text. The main problem is that the text is just too blunt and telegraphic to convey much information. On Martini & Memmi’s The Annunciation, de Rynck identifies the four Old Testament prophets but doesn’t explain why those particular four, what they’re doing there, whether that was a common design element of that genre. In short, everything that I picked up the book for (and in fact didn’t get much beyond 60 pages). A much better approach would have been eight pages for each of 25 paintings which would allow a more detailed exploration as well as background for the artist.
Lyle Rexer’s How to Look at Outsider Art (2005) doesn’t sound particularly promising and lives up to such unpromise. After all, doesn’t outsider art more than any other create its own terms? Not that an introduction or overview wouldn’t be useful but the primary value to Rexer’s book is as a sporadic survey. There are a few interesting artists I didn’t know about and unfamiliar bits about others I did but Rexer is far too mired in run-of-the-mill art critical thinking to help much with this art. In other words, timid and watered-down philosophy takes precedence over actually experiencing the art work. Much of his concern is exterior (outside the outsider art) even leading him to propose a taxonomy based on the mental status of the artist, an activity more appropriate to a therapist than a critic. While such information is undeniably of interest, it’s not the major point. You also wonder about most factual information when he tells us about the Borges story “Tlon, Uqbar, and Orbis Tertius” which manages to have two errors in one title (it’s actually “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” and the umlaut couldn’t have posed a problem considering how often Wölfli is mentioned). Elsewhere he tries to mention a Ken Grimes painting that resembles a circuit diagram as an example of outsiders gravitating to science fiction despite the obvious fact that there’s nothing remotely science fictional about this since it’s based on decades-old electrical symbols.
Though Patrick de Rynck’s How to Read a Painting: Lessons from the Old Masters (2004) seemed more promising, it’s actually of almost no value. The basic idea is to explore important elements of pre-modern painting that elude most of us nowadays. The format is two pages per painting (100 paintings in all) which each work getting a full view then enlargments of specific icons, characters or actions with accompanying text. The main problem is that the text is just too blunt and telegraphic to convey much information. On Martini & Memmi’s The Annunciation, de Rynck identifies the four Old Testament prophets but doesn’t explain why those particular four, what they’re doing there, whether that was a common design element of that genre. In short, everything that I picked up the book for (and in fact didn’t get much beyond 60 pages). A much better approach would have been eight pages for each of 25 paintings which would allow a more detailed exploration as well as background for the artist.
101 best screenplays?
http://www.wga.org/subpage_newsevents.aspx?id=1807
A friend sent this list from the Writer's Guild of the 101 Greatest Screenplays and it's an odd statement. The overall impression isn't that screenplays were judged but that the voting members simply chose the greatest films where the screenplay was clearly the foundation. How else would you account for Citizen Kane when it's obvious that the same script filmed by anybody else but Welles wouldn't have resulted in anything remotely like what we have. Or The Wizard of Oz which owes less to the screenwriters than to the songwriters, actors, set designers and Baum. The number one choice was Casablanca, a routine 40s Warner melodrama that's inexplicably come to be considered A Great Film but which again owes whatever strengths it has to something other than the script. (It probably helps that respected nitwit Robert McKee has praised this particular script, or again the resulting film since it's not clear that he or any of the voters actually read the script.) Being the result of industry voting, the list really just shows writers patting each other on the back. That's why there are no silent films and almost nothing from outside Hollywood.
A friend sent this list from the Writer's Guild of the 101 Greatest Screenplays and it's an odd statement. The overall impression isn't that screenplays were judged but that the voting members simply chose the greatest films where the screenplay was clearly the foundation. How else would you account for Citizen Kane when it's obvious that the same script filmed by anybody else but Welles wouldn't have resulted in anything remotely like what we have. Or The Wizard of Oz which owes less to the screenwriters than to the songwriters, actors, set designers and Baum. The number one choice was Casablanca, a routine 40s Warner melodrama that's inexplicably come to be considered A Great Film but which again owes whatever strengths it has to something other than the script. (It probably helps that respected nitwit Robert McKee has praised this particular script, or again the resulting film since it's not clear that he or any of the voters actually read the script.) Being the result of industry voting, the list really just shows writers patting each other on the back. That's why there are no silent films and almost nothing from outside Hollywood.
Thursday, March 30, 2006
Geoffrey Chaucer Hath a Blog
http://houseoffame.blogspot.com/
I am such a doofus but this made me laugh. Out loud. More than once.
(Especially the discussion of dogs.)
I am such a doofus but this made me laugh. Out loud. More than once.
(Especially the discussion of dogs.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)